There is what is known in screenwriting class as “The Road Movie,” where two characters take a trip together and have an emotional epiphany, being presented with a reason to travel somewhere in the first act, making the journey and having emotional conflict in the second act, and generally repairing some deep emotional damage and restoring a relationship in the third act. You’ve seen these flicks before – Planes, Trains and Automobiles; Harold and Maude; Midnight Run, etc., etc. With this lesson imparted to you, dear reader, and with your having seen the ad campaign for this movie, then surely you have guessed that Trouble With the Curve is of this formula.
Clint Eastwood is Gus Lobell, a
veteran baseball scout who has spent the majority of his working life scouring
the backwoods of the South in search of talent for the Atlanta Braves. Younger
Braves scouts are hell-bent on drafting a young North Carolina high-school
phenom based solely on the numbers he’s produced playing amateur baseball, but
Gus and his boss, Pete (John Goodman) believe in the “eyeball test,” and insist
on visually assessing the player before agreeing he should be a part of the
Braves’ future. Age doing what it does, however,
Gus finds his eyesight failing, which means his ability to give prospective
ballplayers the “eyeball test” will soon be gone, so Pete convinces Gus’s somewhat-estranged
daughter Mickey (Amy Adams) to accompany him on the trip to North Carolina,
even though Mickey is at a critical point in her law career and probably
shouldn’t be leaving and jeopardizing her potential partnership. Gus doesn’t want Mickey tagging along, either,
making Mickey’s task all that much harder, and the attentions of a fellow
scout, played by Justin Timberlake, certainly don’t help matters.
Eastwood plays Gus with almost
the same tone as his character from Grand
Torino and (maybe to a slightly lesser degree) Million Dollar Baby. Amy
Adams, though, is as terrific as usual, taking a sorta-typical Lifetime TV movie-type of character and making us
love her (or maybe that’s just me, given my penchant for blue-eyed,
baseball-loving redheads…). Even Justin
Timberlake does a good job with what he’s given to do, and the energy these three
lead actors bring to their roles is what saves this movie, as most of the other
characters are cartoon-like, almost simplistic in their depiction. The younger scout portrayed by Matthew
Lillard, who I believe is supposed to stereotypically represent the “new
school” of statistic-driven talent evaluation, is so sniveling and comically
evil-doing that I almost felt myself yanked away from a movie and into a sitcom
whenever he appeared onscreen. Mickey’s fellow-lawyer boyfriend is almost a
joke, too, with his logistical analysis of and checklist-like approach to their
relationship.
Even the high-school-aged buffoon
who is the object of all these scouts’ attention is seemingly plucked from one
of those Warner Bros. cartoons, where he was the bulldog who used to beat up on
the Sylvester-looking cat so sadistically.
I don’t doubt for a second that a lot of “bonus babies” signed to big
money right out of high school behave this boorishly, but the movie seems to
almost go to pains to continually portray this kid as an arrogant ass, when the
point was effectively conveyed after his first appearance. Everything after that just seemed like
piling-on. The lack of fleshing-out of
these secondary characters really keeps this movie from feeling like anything
more than a slightly-better-than-average TV movie.
Four years ago, after Grand Torino had its theatrical
run, Clint Eastwood proclaimed he was retiring from acting, as good parts for
80-year olds were too few and far between, so he was going to just stick
to working behind the camera from that point.
This “retirement” lasted all of four years, as what he believed to be a pretty
good part came along after all. He most
likely did this movie as a favor to director Robert Lorenz, a long-time
associate who has worked with Eastwood for two decades as a co-producer and
second unit director. Even though we’ve
seen Eastwood play this character before (in effect, anyway), he plays it so
well that it’s a pleasure to watch. Who
doesn’t find himself snickering when Clint starts ranting in his
sandpaper-and-gravel voice, even if it’s directed at an empty chair on a stage…?
(no political statement implied here).
All told, I was a little disappointed at how
simplistic this movie is. Baseball
scouting and talent evaluation is nowhere near as simple as it is portrayed
here (neither is the legal profession, I’m sure), but a movie story that we’ve
seen before, yet still done well, can be nice to see, and Trouble With the Curve is one of those flicks. It may feel like you’ve seen it several times
before, but the lead actors give such heartfelt performances that even so
predictable a story as this one is fairly enjoyable. I liked it okay, but I’d have been just fine
seeing it on the Hallmark Channel someday instead of forking over eleven bucks
for it.